"All eyes on Syria" - post-Assad Syria needs democracy and civility

TLDR

Yezid Sayigh's "Anatomy of a Military Fall" from the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace and Annie Slemrod's "Syria Faces Huge Humanitarian Challenges as It Begins Post-Assad Era" from The New Humanitarian examine the fall of Bashar al-Assad's regime and the aftermath. Sayigh analyzes the Syrian military's collapse, rooted in mismanagement, corruption, and the loss of foreign support. Slemrod focuses on post-Assad humanitarian crises, highlighting mass displacement, poverty, and governance struggles under rebel leadership. Both emphasize the enormous challenges in Syria's recovery, including rebuilding institutions, addressing humanitarian needs, and fostering international cooperation to stabilize the nation.
 

The Collapse of Assad's Regime: Factors and Dynamics

Yezid Sayigh's "Anatomy of a Military Fall" provides an in-depth analysis of the Syrian regime's downfall, focusing on the structural weaknesses of its military and governance systems. Once a larger force, the Syrian army deteriorated due to years of corruption, mismanagement, and cronyism. Senior military leaders prioritized personal gain over professional standards, eroding trust within the ranks. Poor pay, inadequate supplies, and a lack of coherent strategy led to mass defections and low morale among soldiers.
 
External factors played a significant role in the regime's fall. Assad's dependence on foreign allies, particularly Russia and Iran, left the military vulnerable when these nations diverted resources to other conflicts. Sayigh draws comparisons to authoritarian regimes in Libya and Egypt, noting that the Syrian army lacked the institutional autonomy to act independently. Unlike Egypt's military, which retained its influence after the Arab Spring, the Syrian military was too deeply enmeshed in the regime's power structure to survive its collapse.
 
Another critical factor was Assad's failure to uphold the implicit social contracts that sustained his rule. The regime's reliance on the Alawite community and public sector workers weakened as economic hardships intensified. Assad's inability to address their grievances further alienated these constituencies, accelerating his regime's disintegration. Sayigh emphasizes that the collapse resulted from military failures and a broader erosion of governance and legitimacy.
 

Post-Assad Challenges: Humanitarian and Political Crisis

Annie Slemrod's "Syria Faces Huge Humanitarian Challenges as It Begins Post-Assad Era" highlights Syria's immense challenges in the aftermath of Assad's fall. With over 16.7 million people requiring humanitarian assistance, the country is grappling with unprecedented levels of poverty, displacement, and infrastructure destruction. The report paints a grim picture of daily life in Syria, where basic services like healthcare, education, and clean water are virtually nonexistent.
 
Humanitarian aid, a lifeline for millions, remains heavily politicized and weaponized. Aid organizations face significant obstacles in reaching vulnerable populations, particularly in areas controlled by Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) and other armed groups. Slemrod points out that these groups often exploit aid for their own benefit, undermining efforts to address the needs of civilians. Despite lifting some restrictions, international sanctions and logistical challenges continue to impede effective humanitarian responses.
 
Governance in post-Assad Syria is another critical issue. HTS, which now controls large swathes of territory, has attempted to rebrand itself as a moderate Islamist group. However, questions still need to be answered about its capacity to govern effectively and its commitment to human rights. The lack of a clear political transition plan further complicates efforts to stabilize the country. Slemrod warns that without international engagement, Syria risks descending into prolonged instability akin to the post-Gaddafi chaos in Libya.
 
Economic collapse compounds these challenges. The Syrian pound has plummeted in value, leading to skyrocketing inflation and widespread poverty. Reconstruction efforts are hampered by funding shortages and the reluctance of international donors to engage with rebel-led administrations. Slemrod emphasizes that rebuilding Syria will require significant international cooperation, but political divisions and mistrust among key stakeholders hinder progress.
 

Common Themes

Both texts highlight the fragility of the transition in Syria and its immense challenges. Sayigh's analysis of the regime's collapse provides a critical context for understanding the power vacuum that Slemrod describes. The military's failure to maintain cohesion and the regime's loss of legitimacy created an environment where rebel groups like HTS could gain prominence.
 
The role of external actors is another shared theme. Sayigh discusses how the withdrawal of Russian and Iranian support weakened Assad's regime, while Slemrod highlights how international sanctions and limited aid hinder post-conflict recovery. Both texts emphasize that international engagement will be crucial for Syria's future, though the nature of that engagement remains contested.
 
Finally, both authors underscore the devastating human cost of the conflict. Sayigh focuses on the regime's betrayal of its constituents. At the same time, Slemrod details the daily struggles of Syrians facing starvation, disease, and displacement. These texts provide a comprehensive view of Syria's past and present challenges.
 
 

Concluding Reflections

The combined insights of Yezid Sayigh and Annie Slemrod offer a sobering assessment of Syria's collapse and its uncertain future. Sayigh's analysis of the regime's military and governance failures highlights the structural weaknesses that led to Assad's downfall. His work underscores the importance of institutional resilience and legitimacy in maintaining stability. These lessons extend beyond Syria to other fragile states.
 
Slemrod's focus on the humanitarian and political crises in post-Assad Syria provides a critical lens for understanding the recovery challenges. Her report underscores the need for a coordinated international response to address the immediate needs of Syrians while laying the groundwork for long-term stability. However, the political and logistical obstacles to such efforts remain daunting.
 
Both texts emphasize that Syria's path forward will require balancing immediate humanitarian interventions with broader political solutions. This includes engaging with groups like HTS, despite their controversial histories, and addressing the structural factors that perpetuate instability. As the international community grapples with these challenges, the lessons from Syria serve as a stark reminder of the costs of neglecting governance and humanitarian needs in the wake of conflict.
 
Thanks for reading. Please follow my blog and write your feedback.