Federalism vs populism in the USA

Sanctuary policies, adopted by state and local governments to resist enforcing specific federal laws, are a crucial check on federal power and an embodiment of federalism. These policies prevent federal overreach by allowing states to refuse cooperation, thus preserving local autonomy and diversity. Sanctuary policies are constitutionally protected under the 10th Amendment and serve as a counterbalance to centralizing populist tendencies. While they may weaken some federal law enforcement, they play a vital role in maintaining a balance of power and protecting individual freedoms against potential authoritarianism.

Since the 2016 election, the term 'sanctuary' has taken on a new political and legal significance. Originally, sanctuary policies were adopted by state and local governments to resist enforcing specific federal laws, thereby creating a legal barrier around their jurisdictions. Initially, these policies were focused on immigration, with liberal states and cities implementing measures to prevent local law enforcement from aiding in the deportation of undocumented immigrants not convicted of serious crimes. This approach has since been mirrored by conservative states passing gun-sanctuary laws and refusing to enforce federal gun control laws.

Sanctuary policies, though controversial, have strong constitutional foundations and serve as a vital check on federal power, particularly against overreaching presidents from both parties. The concept of sanctuary jurisdictions is distinct from "nullification," where states claim federal laws are void and actively obstruct their enforcement. Instead, sanctuary jurisdictions deny cooperation, significantly hindering federal enforcement efforts due to the federal system's reliance on state and local law enforcement.

Sanctuary policies derive their constitutional protection from the 10th Amendment, which prevents federal 'commandeering' of state governments, as upheld by several Supreme Court decisions. These rulings affirm that state and local governments cannot be compelled to enforce federal laws, thus supporting the legitimacy of sanctuary policies. In essence, sanctuary policies are not just a form of resistance but also a manifestation of federalism, ensuring that states retain a degree of sovereignty and can act as a check on federal overreach.

The importance of federalism in this context becomes particularly significant in combating populism. Populist leaders often seek to centralize power and impose their will uniformly across the nation, disregarding regional differences and local governance. By empowering states and localities to refuse cooperation with federal mandates, sanctuary policies provide a decentralized counterbalance to such centralizing tendencies. This decentralized approach ensures a diversity of policies and protections that can safeguard individual liberties against potential authoritarian impulses at the federal level.

As reinforced by sanctuary policies, federalism allows states to serve as laboratories of democracy, where diverse policies can be tested and implemented based on local preferences and needs. This decentralization is crucial in a highly diverse nation like the United States, where federally imposed uniformity could deny millions the opportunity to live under policies they prefer. Sanctuary policies also empower people to "vote with their feet" by moving to jurisdictions with more favorable laws, thus promoting a more dynamic and responsive political system.

While sanctuary policies may weaken the enforcement of some federal laws, their role in preserving state diversity, enabling local autonomy, and providing a check on potential authoritarianism is paramount. They are a vital mechanism within the Federalist system, helping to maintain a balance of power and protect individual freedoms in an era of increasing political polarization and populist rhetoric.
 
Thanks for reading. You can support and reward me via: 
Pay Pal — lauvlad89@gmail.com
Algo — NCG6LBALQHENQUSR77KOR6SS42FGK54BZ5L2HFDSBGQVLGYIOVWYDXFDI4
ADA — addr1q9vfs6nqz4xmtnpljwhv4tukyskd2g7enxd87rpugkwwvfun5pnla5d5tes2mvurrc77e7837yd0scrfk063qlha8wgs8d4ynz
Bitcoin 3HbxyDXE9MhNQ8RqsirqgYvFupQzh5Xby2
ETH — 0x8982cdb97bd23f092f78a16a4fc93c5c4607a285
Seeds — vladlausevic
Skycoin — ZxjhWMJRbTNCRQzy5MekZzH4fhdWFCqBP8
Tezos — tz1QrRzkTAKuPKF8dmGW6c1ScEHBUGvoiJBM