WHO declares loneliness as a significant health threat

5tGG...kNBo
22 Nov 2023
89

In recent years, there has been growing alarm among public health experts and policymakers at the prevalence of loneliness in societies across the developed world and its impact as a risk factor for chronic disease and reduced life expectancy. In 2017, former U.S. Surgeon General Vivek Murthy went so far as to declare loneliness an “epidemic”, citing it as prevalent a condition as obesity or substance abuse disorders with concomitant effects on mortality.

The UK and Japan have taken the lead in research on adverse physiological effects of isolation and in 2018, U.K. Prime Minister Theresa May appointed the first Minister for Loneliness to develop a national strategy addressing this public health crisis. Yet, there is still limited public discourse or awareness campaigns around loneliness as a threat to population wellbeing compared to more established public health priorities like nutrition, smoking, or heart disease.

The Physiological Impacts of Loneliness



While colloquially thought of as just a sad emotional state, a widening body of clinical research over the past 40 years connects experiences of loneliness – both sustained isolation and perceived social exclusion – with tangible deterioration in physical health and risk factors for chronic disease, especially among older adults but observed even in younger demographics.

Data first emerged in the late 70’s on increased illness and mortality rates among groups vulnerable to isolation like widowed older adults. Landmark research by Lisa Berkman and S. Leonard Syme found social disconnectedness predictive of strokes and heart attacks independently of traditional risk factors like diet, exercise or smoking. Inflammation biomarkers like C-reactive protein were soon found heightened in lonely individuals along with stress hormones, immune response impairment, metabolic and genetic shifts comparable to health-damaging physical stress.

By the 1990’s, data analysis across 148 separate studies concluded social isolation significantly increased mortality risk by 26% for those reporting few social contacts – on par with risk factors like obesity and smoking. Brain studies later revealed visible detrimental impacts of loneliness on regions like the ventral striatum regulating motivation and reward-processing - showing it operates akin to mental stresses causing lapses in self-control, foresight and habit forming. Across industrialized populations, loneliness has been tied as a predictor to major killers like cardiovascular disease, stroke, Alzheimer’s dementia, clinical depression, and premature death – associations holding after controlling for genetics and mental illness susceptibility.

With an estimated 40% of adults in industrialized nations reporting serious loneliness, the aggregate disease burden may be profound even rivaling major recognized public health challenges like obesity. Yet public discourse and policy action around this prevalent determinant of wellbeing still lags despite documentation of its tangible harm.

Causes and Risk Factors


The obvious question emerges - if humans are inherently such social creatures, why are modern societies experiencing endemic isolation with devastating health outcomes? Rather than any single cause, the present loneliness crisis stems from an interplay of social and cultural shifts in industrialized nations unfolding over recent generations.

Researchers note populations have always had sizeable proportions preferring solitary lives along with more extroverted types. But broader societal conditions historically nurtured wider community belonging. Tendencies towards isolation were also buffered by larger family networks when single households were rarer.

Since the post-war rise of individualistic urbanization, consumer culture and digital media however, conditions eroding communal ties have grown pervasive in everyday life across population segments. Chronic loneliness has transitioned from minority disposition to culture-wide phenomenon, a ‘social recession’ moving alongside economic boom cycles with complex ripple effects.

Marriage rates and nuclear families have sharply declined across Western nations with more adults living alone - trends promising to accelerate. Private transport supersedes public spaces as communal hubs. Inequities in access to essential services compound isolation among groups like the impoverished elderly. Rapidly aging societies face elder care crises with overburdened facilities inadequate to growing needs.

Digital disruption adds paradoxical effects of being more ‘connected’ than ever, while risks of technology dependency and internet compelled ‘iGen’ generations losing core relating skills grow. Rates of meaningful in-person friendship for all ages have dropped per capita. With the COVID-19 pandemic likely triggering lasting shifts in remote work and ecommerce, regaining older communal rhythms faces hurdles. In effect, present social conditions make experiencing loneliness almost inevitable over a lifetime. The crisis lies in chronic sustained isolation without relief, support or coping skills to break free of isolation’s impacts.

The Japanese Phenomenon – High Suicide Rates and the “Solo Tribe” Culture


While social isolation has grown markedly across OECD nations, Japan offers a sobering case study of cultural transformation since 1990’s economic recession. Despite maintaining lower obesity levels than Western states, Japan holds the highest national rates globally for early mortality and mental illnesses like clinical depression – conditions scientifically linked to endemic loneliness.

Reference to isolation permeates Japanese society, from the phenomenon of “hikikomori” - hundreds of thousands of youth withdrawn from society for years confined in their bedrooms to widespread alienating pressures behind Asia’s highest suicide rates. Japanese media shapes narratives of a “solo-tribe” culture with once secure societal collectivism unraveling into social fragmentation and despair epidemic.

Demographics of Japanese households shifted starkly over 30 years from multi-generational family units towards dual income nuclear families and radically smaller single dwellings. This deprived younger residents of extended familial support systems unlike prior generations. Rigid hierarchies plus expectations to subordinate personal lives to employers left white collar workers starved of deeper social connections.

Retirees also fell victim to isolation in aging communities unaccustomed to proactively building independent peer networks, after being uprooted from lifelong corporate identities. Bereft of adequate elderly care infrastructure, older relatives often suffer alone – a crisis reflected in annual statistics of over 20,000 Japanese elders perishing unattended and isolated in kodokushi “lonely deaths”.

For younger Japanese adults, pressure-cooker education systems and economic insecurity confer excessive social pressures - driving withdrawal from society for some unable to meet standards of success. Friendships and relationships grow more strained and transactional. Despite Japan’s reputation for community solidarity, beneath the surface lies an increasingly disconnected nation with millions suffering apart in silence. Pervasive isolation has emerged as both symptom and reinforcing driver of societal malaise.

Wider Social Implications


Reframing loneliness as a public health priority holds promise addressing quality of life deficits and vulnerability across communities – especially for youth and aging groups. But the crisis equally exposes limitations around overmedicalizing societal problems without attention to economic policies and reversal of the social fabric fraying for generations.

Research on adverse health impacts of isolation comports with deeper realities of human psychology – that social wounds impact bodily wellbeing and human flourishing fundamentally relates to the vitality or deprivation of communal ties. Healing from loneliness cannot simply be packaged as another lifestyle regulated by clinics or public health decrees. A healthier society necessitates rebuilding those connections fermenting purpose and belonging in daily life.

Rising inequality, housing crises pricing out communities and opioids filling spiritual voids point to economic priorities radically outpacing social investments for too long. Governments preoccupied with aggregate growth rates and corporate priorities have tacitly accepted the implicit tradeoffs – including the loss for many of those nourishing bonds and rituals integral to human meaning, maturation and development.

Reclaiming spaces for communal life and prioritizing social infrastructure – from childcare systems relieving overstressed dual income homes to revitalizing town centres and places celebrating public creativity – offers pathways restoring frayed communal fabric over generations before chronic isolation became endemic.

Policy Ideas and Loneliness Interventions


In response to the growing consensus on detrimental health impacts of loneliness, policy programs piloting interventions have arisen in various countries – from publicly funding community spaces and group activities to training health providers to assess social connectedness alongside diet or exercise.

The UK appointed its first Minister of Loneliness 2018 to coordinate across agencies, followed by Japan, Canada and other states. Pilot municipal programs like Sweden’s “culture for health” initiative have invested in accessible cultural hubs and group events seeing marked reductions regionally in health service usage. Multi-layered policy efforts emphasizing mental health alongside housing affordability help reduce the burden of isolation facing disadvantaged groups.

Social prescribing programs allow doctors to refer patients to community agencies and peer groups as readily as pharmaceutical options. Group parenting classes open to all caregivers cultivate solidarity and networks buffering isolation in childrearing. Neighbourhood beautification drives enhance local interactions countering urban alienation.

Non-profits training proactive community building and one-to-one outreach to marginalized residents prevent social exclusion compounding chronic isolation. Key is recognizing policies strengthening communal life merit parallel importance to infrastructure assets like transit or digital access.

Personalized interventions show promise assisting the severely isolated to gradually reconnect and gain independent living skills at their own pace. Cognitive approaches address thought patterns undermining motivation and self-worth maintaining withdrawal from society. Japan’s youth mental health system deploys outreach workers to meet hikikomori where they are, coaxing gradual engagement without pressure.

Multipronged strategies sensitive to intersectional barriers homogenized programs ignore have succeeded better than fragmented interventions - integrating counselling, skills training, job placement and flexible spaces welcoming marginalized groups without stigma is ideal.

Loneliness at endemic scale signifies ruptured social equilibrium - one requiring holistic restoration or societies risk compounding alienation. But the same bonds enabling human flourishing since the dawn of civilization endure as a wellspring for regeneration. Healing the loneliness crisis begins with compassionate spaces welcoming people back whole.

Get fast shipping, movies & more with Amazon Prime

Start free trial

Enjoy this blog? Subscribe to CapitalThink

9 Comments