EU, Spain and migration - going against the trend?

TLDR

Spain is among the few EU countries pursuing a more progressive migration policy. Under Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez, the country has embraced a more open and inclusive approach driven by pragmatism and moral conviction. Spain sees migration as a solution to its economic and demographic challenges, contrasting sharply with other EU countries that view migration primarily as a threat. Despite this, Spain has faced criticism for handling border controls and integration challenges.
 
 

Spain Bucks the Trend in the EU

While several European countries close their borders and tighten migration regulations, Spain has chosen a different path. Under Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez and his Socialist Workers' Party (PSOE), the country has taken a clear stance in favor of a more open migration policy. This approach is a moral position and a strategy to address Spain's demographic and economic challenges.

Spain's aging population and low birth rates threaten its future welfare system and labor market. Sánchez has argued that migration is a humanitarian obligation necessary to secure the country's economic stability. He contends that migrants are vital for filling labor shortages and supporting the pension system.

Unlike Italy, where Giorgia Meloni advocates for closed borders and strict restrictions, Spain has actively welcomed migrants. This is part of a broader vision to create a more inclusive and economically sustainable society.

To justify his policy, Sánchez also highlighted Spain's historical experience as a nation of immigrants, especially during the Franco era. The country has a moral responsibility to welcome people fleeing war and poverty. This stance reflects a deep conviction that migration can positively affect both host countries and migrants.
 
 

Criticism and Challenges

Despite its progress, Spain has not escaped criticism. "Tough" border controls, particularly at the Moroccan border, have led to tragedies such as the incident at Melilla, where several migrants lost their lives. Critics argue that this highlights a contradiction in Spain's migration policy: welcoming migrants on the one hand while employing harsh methods to control borders on the other.

Integration also remains a challenge. Bureaucratic hurdles and local tensions have often made it difficult for migrants to integrate fully into Spanish society. This creates risks of marginalization and exploitation, which could undermine the long-term goals of Spain's migration policy.

Spain challenges the EU's dominant narrative on migration, which often relies on fear and exclusion. The country's policy reminds us that an alternative path is possible based on solidarity, sustainability, and human rights. By emphasizing the positive aspects of migration, Spain offers an alternative model for addressing migration in a globalized world.
 
 

Reflective Summary

Spain demonstrates a different migration policy, rooted in pragmatism and moral conviction rather than fear and exclusion, is possible. By welcoming migrants to solve economic and demographic challenges, Spain presents an inspiring but imperfect model.

The country faces significant challenges, particularly in integrating migrants and managing border controls. At the same time, Spain defies the EU's conservative trend on migration, showing that migration can be seen as a resource rather than a threat. The future will reveal whether Spain's strategy can serve as a model for other countries.
 
Thanks for reading. Please follow my blog and write your feedback.